Let’s understand the key differences between TPM and HSM in terms of functionality, key features, use cases, scope, key storage management, and other aspects.
We are living in a world where data security plays a key role in business. Also, we know that there’s always a fear of cyberattacks, and global cyberattacks reached an all-time high with an average of 1168 weekly attacks per organization.
Therefore, many organizations started using security modules to protect their data and applications from unauthorized access, tampering, and other security threats.
There are two security modules or technologies that organizations are using, such as:
TPM (Trusted Platform Module)
HSM (Hardware Security Module)
Both aim to protect data; they have unique characteristics and functions. When Microsoft launched Windows 11, TPM was crucial for devices eligible to run the OS. Similarly, HSM is also a vital standard storage device that secures stored data.
Also, lots of people ask if TPM can be used as an HSM? So, the answer is yes because TPM allows basic cryptographic operations and stowing keys, which is more of a similar thing to an HSM.
While both are important for data protection, which is more important for your business?
In this article, we will compare TPM vs. HSM in accordance with their key features, and find differences to understand which module is best.
What is TPM?
A Trusted Platform Module (TPM) is a small chip built into computer systems to improve security features. It ensures a secure environment for critical operations like cryptographic key generation, storage, secure boot, and authentication.
TPM is a trusted anchor, ensuring a system’s sensitive information integrity. It employs cryptographic encryption to ensure the data on a computer is secure.
BitLocker drive encryption, Windows Hello, and other services are using TPM to secure and store cryptographic keys. The reason is because it ensures that the OS and firmware on your system are what they need to be and haven’t been tampered with.
TPM has been around for over 20 years and has been an important part of PCS since 2005.
When to Use a Trusted Platform Module (TPM)?
- To authenticate the integrity of a system by making sure that the system boots using real software by the system manufacturer.
- To protect and store security keys
- To authenticate system integrity when you need to grant specific data access.
- Secure sensitive data used in enterprise environments
Key Features of TPM
Secure Startup
TPM performs a self-check and verifies the system’s integrity whenever you start a computer.
Key Generation and Storage
It generates and stores encryption keys to encrypt data or authenticate users.
Platform Authentication
TPM uses remote attestation to verify that the platform’s integrity is intact for operating systems and third-party entities.
Secure Storage and Encryption
TPM provides a secure area called the Trusted Platform Module Security Storage Root Key (SRK). You can use SRK to store keys, SSL certificates, and other sensitive data.
Secure Key Management
You can manage keys securely within TPM, which provides an isolated environment from the OS. This ensures secure operations such as key generation, import/export, and wrapping/unwrapping.
Secure Communication
TPM enables secure communication between entities, ensuring confidential, integral, and authentic data exchange.
What is an HSM?
The Hardware Security Module (HSM) is a dedicated hardware device that enables cryptographic encryption and helps you store sensitive information securely.
Keeping the information safe is crucial, especially if you are a financial organization, healthcare service provider, or government authority.
HSM can help by keeping sensitive, key information separate from the main system. According to 360 market updates, the HSM market is projected to reach $2758.8 million by the end of 2026.
In general, there are two main uses for HSMs: one for general purposes and one for payments.
HSMs can use common encryption algorithms such as CAPI, CNG, and others. For payments and transactions, HSMs are used to protect payment card information and other important transaction data.
When to Use a Hardware Security Module (HSM)?
- To protect sensitive cryptographic keys and perform high-profile cryptographic operations.
- To store cryptographic keys in a tamper-proof environment.
- To protect processing of transactions and handle high-speed cryptographic operations.
- To generate and manage digital certificates by a Certificate Authority (CA)
- To secure authentication and verification processes.
- One can use HSM for a secure code signing.
Key Features of HSM
Secure Key Management
You can use Hardware Security Modules to ensure the secure management of private keys, which is crucial for any organization.
Cryptographic Acceleration
You can leverage HSM for hardware-based cryptographic acceleration, enabling faster and more efficient operations.
Tamper Resistance
Hardware Security Modules (HSMs) can withstand tampering, providing a formidable barrier against attackers seeking to steal critical key data.
Compliance Support
Storing vital information securely is crucial for HSMs to ensure compliance with industry standards and data regulations.
TPM vs. HSM: Understanding the Differences
To find the difference between TPM vs HSM, it is important to understand their purpose.
TPM is for computer hardware and firmware security, while HSM is for cryptographic keys and other important data.
When it comes to security, HSM is more secure than TPM.
Let’s understand the key differences between TPM and HSM in terms of functionality, scope, key storage management, and other aspects.
#1. The purpose of the security device
TPM and HSM offer secure key management, but their functionality is a major difference. For example, TPM is integrated within a computer, securing the entire system, compared to HSM, which stores the data on a device.
#2. Scope of Use
Integrating it into the motherboard lets you use TPM to secure laptops, desktops, and other devices. At the same time, HSMs are mostly used in organizations, institutions, or as separate devices that store the security key pairs.
#3. Features and Functionality
TPM ensures that a computer loads only trusted software during the system boot process. It verifies the integrity of the system’s firmware, BIOS, and other critical components. TPM also provides encryption and decryption services for system-level data protection.
On the other hand, HSM allows you to store cryptographic keys, preventing unauthorized data access and system tampering. It also enables key generation using a random number generator.
#4. Key Storage and Management
TPM and HSM both protect your cryptographic keys from unauthorized access and tampering. TPM stores keys securely within your device, while HSM offers dedicated hardware for key storage, management, backup, and separation of access control.
#5. Performance and Speed
TPM provides security at the device level, focusing on integrity and protection. It may not offer the same performance and speed level as HSMs, which are specifically designed for cryptographic operations.
Conclusion
It is important to recognize the distinct roles that TPM and HSM play in enhancing data security. While TPM focuses on securing the device and its internal operations, HSM specializes in key management and cryptographic operations.
Depending on your organization’s needs, you may implement TPM for device-level security or opt for HSM for dedicated key management and cryptographic acceleration. Understanding these differences allows you to select the right solution to safeguard sensitive information.
Related Articles:
- Top Changes in Issuing OV Code Signing Certificate After June 1st, 2023
- What is Code Signing Certificate? How Does it Work?
- The Detailed Guide to Code Signing Certificate Best Practices
- Code Signing Certificate – Upgrade Security with 3072-bit Key Length
- EV Code Signing vs. Regular Code Signing : Decode the Differences
